Multiplication and Division Equations: Finding the Unknown
Updated: Nov 12
We can put multiplication and division equations on a turkey, tuck them into a house, or give the numbers family roles. But what mathematical thinking does the activity actually ask students to do?
A completed page shows that students recorded related equations. It doesn’t tell us whether they can use those relationships to find an unknown—the work required by 3.OA.A.4.
When Memorable is not Mathematical

If students only copy three numbers into four familiar equation formats, the turkey may show careful work without revealing why the equations belong together. The problem is not the decoration. It is a task students can finish without using the mathematics.
The same problem can hide in our explanations. A story may be easy to remember without helping students understand the idea behind it. I know because I’ve used those stories myself.
In my professional learning workshops, I often share stories about the things I did when I first started teaching. Here’s one I’m not sure I’ve shared yet: I used to describe like terms as having the same last name. I may even have gone as far as saying that 4x and 4x² weren’t like terms because one was Frank and the other was Franklin.
Adding “lin” to a name doesn’t help students understand that x² means x • x. My analogy offered a way to sort symbols without explaining what those symbols represented.
What the Standards Require: Understanding Multiplication and Division Relationships
I can give my earlier teaching self some grace without defending those choices today. I used those explanations before the current standards were in place. The Common Core State Standards and the state standards built from them, including the New Jersey Student Learning Standards for Mathematics, didn’t make mathematical understanding important for the first time. But they made the expectations more explicit: students need to connect ideas and use relationships, not simply remember a procedure.
For 3.OA.A.4, students must determine an unknown whole number in a multiplication or division equation relating three whole numbers, with the unknown in different positions. Calling the smallest number the “baby” doesn’t help students determine what an unknown represents. Understanding how we got here doesn’t mean we should stay here. We have a responsibility to examine whether the stories we tell and the activities we choose help students understand the mathematics—or simply make a rule easier to remember.
So the next step is not a better way to remember where the numbers go. It is to build a relationship students can use when a different quantity is unknown.
Build Multiplication and Division Relationships with One Model
In this week’s Math Standard Monday video, I use bar models to show how four groups of 6 and six groups of 4 make the same total of 24. Students can build these relationships by comparing lengths and counting equal groups, even before they know 4 × 6 = 24 from memory.
This builds on Grade 2 work in 2.OA.C.4: using equal addends to find totals in arrays of up to five rows and five columns. The Grade 3 example extends that reasoning from counting equal groups to connecting multiplication and division.
The instructional payoff is not simply recording a set of equations after watching the model. It is recognizing how one relationship supports another. In 4 × 6 = 24, four groups of 6 make the total. In 24 ÷ 6 = 4, that same total and group size determine how many groups there are. The light-green bars connect 6 × 4 = 24 with 24 ÷ 4 = 6. The quantities stay connected even as the question changes.

Students can see why 4 × 6 and 6 × 4 have the same value without needing to name the commutative property. As these relationships become familiar, students can use them without rebuilding every fact. The model remains available when they need to reconnect a symbol to a quantity; removing it is not a prerequisite for working with unknowns.
This connects to last week’s work with the equal sign: equal means the same value. Using one consistent unit, the matching lengths make that equality visible. The strips have different-sized parts, but the same total length—so four groups of 6 and six groups of 4 both represent 24.
The Number on the Left Does Not Choose the Operation
Why does a fact family so often stop at four equations? We typically record 4 × 6 = 24, 6 × 4 = 24, 24 ÷ 6 = 4, and 24 ÷ 4 = 6. But each equation is still true when we switch the entire left and right sides. If 4 × 6 = 24 is true, then so is 24 = 4 × 6.
That gives us eight ways to write these relationships, not just four. Including both arrangements reinforces what the equal sign means: the two sides have the same value.
A rule like “when the whole comes first, divide” can lead students to choose an operation based on where a number appears rather than how the quantities are related. A student following that rule might write 24 = 6 ÷ 4 simply because 24 is on the left.
But putting 24 first doesn’t change the relationship: six groups of 4 still make 24. The light-green bars help students see why 24 = 6 × 4 is true. If we ask how many groups of 4 make 24, we can write 24 ÷ 4 = 6 or 6 = 24 ÷ 4.
The operation comes from the relationship we’re representing, not the position of the total. That’s why students need opportunities to connect equations to quantities, rather than memorize where each number goes.

Use Multiplication and Division Relationships to Find Unknowns
Unknown products and quotients, such as 4 × 6 = ? and 24 ÷ 4 = ?, are often the go-to examples. But 3.OA.A.4 asks students to find unknowns in different positions, including factors, dividends, and divisors. The goal is to use the same relationship flexibly, rather than learn a separate rule for where the question mark appears.
Keep the three bar strips available as needed, and replace one number with a question mark:
4 × ? = 24
? × 4 = 24
24 ÷ ? = 6
? ÷ 6 = 4
Knowing 4 × 6 = 24 helps students determine that the unknown in 24 ÷ ? = 6 is 4: they need the number that, multiplied by 6, makes 24. In ? ÷ 6 = 4, the missing quantity is instead the whole, 24. The same relationship answers a different question.
This is also the work of 3.OA.B.6: understanding division as an unknown-factor problem. To find 24 ÷ 6, students can ask what number multiplied by 6 makes 24. Determining unknowns, understanding division, and developing fluency are interconnected ideas—not isolated skills.
Then vary the orientation: 6 = 24 ÷ ?. Replacing the question mark with the value students find lets them check that both sides have the same value.
This lays the groundwork for 6.EE.B.5, where students use substitution to determine whether a value from a specified set makes an equation or inequality true, deepening the idea that a solution must make the mathematical statement true.
Connected Relationships, Not Disconnected Facts
Finding 4 in 24 ÷ ? = 6 reinforces the same relationship students use to recall 24 ÷ 4 = 6. The commutative relationship in 3.OA.B.5 extends those connections: knowing 4 × 6 = 24 also gives students 6 × 4 = 24.
Consider positive factors 1–10. The 100 multiplication facts and 100 related division facts can be organized around 55 unordered factor-pair relationships. The pair 4 and 6 connects the four operation facts illustrated above; each can be written with either side of the equality first. For equal factors, such as 4 × 4 = 16, reversing the factor order does not produce another distinct equation.

The 1–10 table is an illustration, not the exact limit of the standards. 3.OA.A.4 does not set that factor range. 3.OA.C.7 addresses multiplication and division within 100 and, by the end of Grade 3, knowing products of two one-digit numbers from memory. The positive-factor example above excludes zero; zero facts need their own attention, including that division by zero is undefined.
This is not a smaller memorization list. It is a way to use known facts to build other facts—and to recover an unknown. Connected understanding supports the accurate, efficient work expected in 3.OA.C.7.
Try Create–Swap–Explain
To give students practice using these connections, try this week’s Create–Swap–Explain activity. Partners use known multiplication relationships to create and solve equations with different quantities unknown. A shared fact and model can support students who need them.
Create: Each partner draws an assignment card specifying the operation, unknown quantity, and equation orientation, then writes a related equation on a whiteboard.
Swap: Exchange whiteboards. Each partner determines the unknown and uses a known relationship or a labeled model to support the value.
Explain and check: Partners substitute the value in the original equation and compare their reasoning. Both sides must have the same value.
The activity includes teacher directions, reusable assignment cards, and optional leaf templates for a “Fall Into Connections” display. After the partner work, each student chooses a leaf, records two connected equations, and completes the thought, “Knowing ___ helps me know ___ because ___.”

This brings us back to the fact-family turkey. The seasonal theme isn’t the problem; what matters is the thinking the task asks students to do. Rather than copy numbers into familiar spaces, students show how a known relationship helps them determine an unknown. The leaf gives them a place to share that connection, and the display makes their thinking visible.
That’s how the activity stays grounded in 3.OA.A.4 while supporting fluency: students use multiplication and division relationships to make sense of what is missing.
Keep the Connections Growing
The connections in this post reach beyond one multiplication fact or one grade level. Students build on equal-addend work, use multiplication and division relationships to find unknowns, and develop an understanding of what an unknown represents and what makes a value a solution. Those ideas lay the foundation for their later work with equations. Seeing these connections helps us make more intentional choices about what we ask students to do today.
That’s the kind of work we explore in our Standards Summits: looking closely at what the standards require, how mathematical ideas develop across grades, and what those connections mean for instruction. We bring the standards into focus through mathematics, models, and practical classroom decisions.
Want to keep exploring those ideas with us? We’re giving away a set of the same EAI Magnetic Bar Models used in this week’s video! Our emails will share details on how to enter this month’s giveaway and keep you informed about upcoming professional learning opportunities, including the Standards Summits.
Subscribe to Coaching That Counts and let’s make the math count! ➕





Comments