top of page

Building Algebraic Reasoning: Equivalent Expressions

6 days ago
8 min read

Updated: 3 days ago

Building algebraic reasoning takes more than teaching students to follow a set of steps. A student may be able to distribute correctly without understanding why the expression they create is equivalent to the one they started with.


I spend so much time talking about K–5 math these days that you might not realize I taught middle school for more than 10 years, including before the Common Core State Standards were adopted. I taught everything from Grade 6 math through Algebra 1.


Once upon a time, I would have handed my students a Kuta Software worksheet to practice distributing. And I still see worksheets like this in many middle school classrooms. But a skill and a standard aren’t always the same thing.


Does Every Factored Expression Need the Greatest Common Factor?


Kuta Software’s Distributive Property, Algebraic worksheet includes three kinds of work: deciding whether expressions are equivalent, distributing to create an equivalent expression, and factoring out the GCF to create an equivalent expression. There are useful opportunities here. The question I want to examine is what happens when we treat one direction on a worksheet as the whole mathematical goal.


what is algebraic reasoning
Excerpt from Kuta Software’s Distributive Property, Algebraic worksheet, Infinite Grade 6 Math. The direction specifies the GCF; 6.EE.A.3 does not prescribe that as the only way to generate an equivalent expression.

Factoring out the greatest common factor can be useful practice with the distributive property in reverse. But is the greatest common factor the only way to generate an equivalent expression?


Consider 45a + 15b. Students might write 15(3a + b), factoring out the greatest common numerical factor. They could also write 5(9a + 3b). Both expressions are equivalent to the original, even though only one factors out the GCF of the coefficients.


equivalent expressions math
Different common factors generate different forms of the same expression. Equivalence is not limited to the GCF form.

Grade 6 students do learn about greatest common factors of whole numbers in 6.NS.B.4. That standard also asks students to use the distributive property to express a sum of two whole numbers from 1–100 as a multiple of a sum whose addends have no common factor greater than 1. Those are specific expectations for whole numbers. They do not make factoring every algebraic expression by the GCF the required endpoint of 6.EE.A.3.

When the task is to generate an equivalent expression, both 15(3a + b) and 5(9a + 3b) deserve attention. How could students show that each expression has the same value

as 45a + 15b?


A response of 5(9a + 3b) would not meet this worksheet’s specific direction to factor out the GCF. It would still be equivalent to 45a + 15b. That distinction matters: following a direction and demonstrating the full meaning of a standard are not the same thing.

This is why I lead with the standards. They help me identify the mathematical goal before deciding which tasks to use, what additional questions to ask, and how to interpret students’ responses. We can value accurate practice without letting a prescribed final form become the definition of understanding.


In Multiplication and Division Equations: Finding the Unknown, I raised a similar question about completed fact-family pages: are students using relationships, or simply recording equations in a familiar format? Here, too, the important question is what students must understand to do the work.


What Makes Expressions Equivalent?


Equivalent expressions have the same value for every permissible value of their variables. They can look different while representing the same quantity. In Building Algebraic Thinking: Understanding the Equal Sign, I explored why calculating correctly does not necessarily mean understanding equality. That distinction still matters when numbers

and letters appear together.


Grade 6 makes these related expectations explicit. 6.EE.A.3 asks students to “Apply the properties of operations to generate equivalent expressions.” The neighboring standard, 6.EE.A.4, asks students to identify when expressions are equivalent, regardless of which number is substituted. Generating a new expression and understanding why it remains equivalent belong together.


Students may simplify as part of this work, but 6.EE.A.3 does not require every expression to be put into a particular simplified form. Simplification does not make one equivalent form more correct than another. The examples in 6.EE.A.3 use the distributive property in both directions and connect repeated addition with multiplication. Students need to understand why those changes preserve value, not simply which sequence of steps produces

the expected form.


The Progressions for the Common Core State Standards for Mathematics (Introduction, pp. 7–8) explain that skills traditionally described as simplification are included, while a simplified form is not automatically the most useful form for every purpose. I do not want students to think their job is always to remove parentheses and make an expression shorter. I want them to understand what changed, what stayed the same, and why.


Change What the Task Asks Students to Reveal


Consider these two ways to work with the same expression.


Practice prompt: Expand 3(x + 4).


Reasoning prompt: Write an expression equivalent to 3(x + 4). Explain why your expression has the same value. Can you connect both expressions to a model?


Both prompts can lead to 3x + 12. The difference is the evidence of algebraic reasoning we ask students to provide. In the second, a student might describe three equal groups of the entire quantity x + 4. That explanation gives meaning to multiplying both terms: three copies of x and three copies of 4.

A rectangle with dimensions 3 and x + 4 can support the explanation when x represents a positive length. The model illustrates the relationship; the distributive property explains the identity more generally. Ask students to connect each factor and term to the quantities

in their model, rather than treating the picture as a separate step.


Then reverse the starting point. Given 3x + 12, can students generate a product that represents the same quantity? They might also decompose 3x to write x + 2x + 12. That expression is less compact, but still equivalent. Ask students how they know their new expression has the same value as the original. Generating equivalent expressions does not require every response to expand a product or reduce the number of terms.


Connect Partial Sums to Algebraic Reasoning


To understand Grade 6 algebra, it can help to look back as far as Grade 1. In 1.NBT.B.2 and 1.NBT.C.4, students develop tens-and-ones reasoning and use place value and properties to explain addition. Those ideas support partial sums: when adding 32 + 15, students can regroup the same quantities without changing the total.


32 + 15 = (3 tens + 1 ten) + (2 ones + 5 ones) = 4 tens + 7 ones = 47


We can connect that structure to 


3x + 2y + x + 5y = (3x + x) + (2y + 5y) = 4x + 7y


Reordering and regrouping bring together copies of the same quantity. This reasoning is more meaningful than a rule to look for matching letters.


equivalent expressions math
Building algebraic reasoning from partial sums: combine counts of the same quantity without changing the total.

The analogy has a limit worth making explicit. Tens and ones are fixed place-value units. The quantities represented by x and y are not: x does not always mean ten, and y does not always mean one. We are connecting the reasoning about what is being counted,

not assigning permanent place values to variables.


Without a relationship between x and y, we cannot generally combine 4x + 7y into a single like term. And in 3x + 2, the 2 represents two ones, not two copies of x, so 5x is not generally equivalent. Ask students what each term counts. Combining like terms can produce a more compact expression, but it is one way to generate an equivalent form, not a requirement that every expression be made shorter.


Use Students’ Explanations to Decide What Comes Next


To support algebraic reasoning, choose follow-up questions based on the thinking students reveal. Consider how you might respond in each of these situations.


If a student writes 3x + 4 for 3(x + 4), ask what is repeated three times. Does each group include the 4, or is there only one 4 in the entire collection? Reconnect the multiplication to the whole quantity before supplying another reminder to distribute.


If a student writes 3x + 12 but explains only “I multiplied everything,” ask what the 12 represents and why adding 3x gives the same value as the original expression. A correct result is a starting point for finding out more, not proof that the relationship is understood.

If a student checks one value and says the expressions are equivalent, ask what that check establishes. One counterexample can disprove equivalence, but one matching result cannot prove it. For example, x + 4 and 2x agree when x = 4, but not when x = 1.


One matching result does not establish equivalence.
 A matching result at one value does not show that two expressions are equivalent for every allowed value.

These questions do not replace practice. They help us choose practice that addresses a specific learning need: interpreting a product, connecting quantities to symbols, or explaining why value is preserved.


Build Algebraic Reasoning Across Grades


The distributive property has an elementary foundation, too. Grade 3’s 3.OA.B.5 asks students to use properties as strategies for multiplication and division. In Multiplication Facts: Strategies Beyond Memorization, I explore how known products help students reason about other products. For example, 2 × 7 can be understood as (2 × 2) + (2 × 5): two groups of 2 and two groups of 5 still make the same total.


In Grade 6, 2(x + 5) = 2x + 10 expresses the same distributive relationship. Two copies of the entire quantity include two copies of x and two copies of 5. Moving from 2x + 10 back to 2(x + 5) preserves the value, too. The property connects the forms in both directions; it is not just an instruction to remove parentheses. Both forms are valid; 6.EE.A.3 does not mandate one of them as the final answer.


Using both the distributive property and combining like terms to generate equivalent expressions.
Place-value reasoning and multiplication properties give students meanings to extend when they generate equivalent expressions in Grade 6.

That foundation matters when signed numbers enter the work. Grade 7’s 7.NS.A develops operations with signed rational numbers, and 7.EE.A.1 applies properties to linear expressions with rational coefficients. Grade 6 can develop equivalence with quantities students already understand, without requiring signed-number operations they have not yet learned.


The purpose still guides the form. Expanding may make terms easier to collect; a factored form may make a relationship easier to use. Grade 7’s 7.EE.A.2 explicitly develops interpreting how rewritten expressions reveal relationships in a problem context. We can build toward that work without making it an additional sixth-grade requirement.

Next week, we’ll see how this understanding carries into solving equations, and why distributing first isn’t always the most efficient choice.


Put the Connections to Work


Watch this week’s Math Standard Monday video for an area-model example of generating equivalent expressions. Then use the free companion Which One Doesn’t Belong? activity to explore the connections from another angle.


In the Which One Doesn’t Belong? activity, students compare expressions, choose one that does not belong, and explain a mathematical reason for their choice. Invite more than one defensible response, and distinguish a difference in form from a difference in value. Follow up by asking students to generate another expression equivalent to one they chose

and explain why.


As students work, listen for what each expression represents, what stays unchanged, and how they explain the connection. A simplified expression is one equivalent form, not the only acceptable destination. The goal is not just a page of answers. It is reasoning students can use again.


Keep the Connections Growing


Building algebraic reasoning does not begin when letters first appear in an expression. The tens-and-ones reasoning of Grade 1 and the multiplication properties of Grade 3 help us see what Grade 6 students can build on. Tracing those connections is not about assigning younger students algebra worksheets. It is about developing meanings they can extend when the notation changes.


That’s the kind of work we explore in our upcoming Standards Summits: looking closely at what the standards require, tracing how mathematical ideas develop across grades, and considering what those connections mean for instruction. We bring the standards into focus through mathematics, models, and practical classroom decisions.


Explore the Standards Summits for Grades K–2, 3–5, and 6–8, and join us to keep making these connections.


algebraic reasoning in math






Comments


© 2026 by Coaching that Counts. Powered and secured by Wix

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

bottom of page